Users don't see the connection between your price and the value they get
Charge based on the metric that most closely represents value to the customer. When price scales with value, upgrades feel natural.
When to use
Your current pricing metric doesn't align with how customers perceive value.
Hypothesis template
If we align pricing to fill in: value metric instead of fill in: current metric, willingness to pay will increase by fill in: target% because customers see direct ROI.
Method
The problem: You charge per seat but your value comes from usage. Or you charge a flat fee when heavy users get 10x more value than light users. The disconnect makes your price feel arbitrary.
What Intercom did: Shifted from per-seat pricing to pricing based on people reached (their value metric). Customers understood: the more people you reach, the more value you get, the more you pay.
The result: Value-aligned pricing increases willingness to pay because customers see direct cause and effect. "I used more, I got more value, I pay more" feels fair.
How to do it:
- Identify your value metric: what do customers get more of when they get more value? (messages sent, experiments run, contacts managed, revenue generated)
- Survey 10 customers: "What would you pay based on [value metric]?"
- Model the pricing: would customers pay more or less than current pricing?
- Test the new model with new signups while grandfathering existing users
- Track: conversion rate, expansion revenue, churn rate, customer satisfaction
- Iterate based on feedback
Key insight: The best value metric is one the customer can control and that correlates with the value they receive. If they can't control it, it feels like a trap.
Success metrics
- •Willingness to pay
- •Conversion rate with new pricing
- •Expansion revenue rate
- •Customer satisfaction score
Prerequisites
- Data on what metric correlates with customer value
- Customer feedback on pricing fairness
- Ability to model alternative pricing structures
Common pitfalls
- •Picking a metric customers can't predict or control
- •Making pricing too complex to understand
- •Not grandfathering existing customers
- •Changing pricing too frequently
Source: Intercom, Segment, Twilio. Value-aligned pricing increases willingness to pay and reduces churn.
Suggested ICE scores
Ready to run this experiment?
Sign up free to use this playbook with step-by-step guidance and track your results.